Imaginative film showing how automatic gadgets in homes and workplaces alienate people from one another.
"Shows the modern family enslaved by automatic gadgets in homes and businesses. Family members go through the days with no real person-to-person contact because everything is done automatically. Emphasis is placed on life being more than just a robot existence."
Contains excellent breakfast scene: businessman awakened by alarm clock,
lets wife sleep as he makes own breakfast (cu coffee pot, waffles in
toaster, etc.), businessman backs his late 1950s Cadillac out of driveway;
great LA FREEWAY scenes (oddly, the background audio is a radio show
playing 1920s records; it's truly bizarre to hear a 20s record juxtaposed
with late 1950s LA Freeway traffic). Downtown Los Angeles. CU hand honking
automobile horn. Driver speaks on two-way car radio; pulls into below
ground parking garage. Much more; excellent "slice of life" late 1950s ftg.
June 17, 2017 Subject:
I Enjoyed This
The camera focuses on the many machines that help humans run their lives. So far, so good. With a few exceptions, the machines are working the way they are designed to.
Eventually you realize that no one in the movie has any face-to-face interpersonal contact for more than a moment or two.
But the machines are not to blame. They only allow people to ignore each other more efficiently.
The movie is really about the inability of humans to truly connect with others on a personal level. The machines make this easier and more comfortable, but they are by no means the source of the problem. They only provide the distraction we seize on to escape from revealing our true selves to others.
December 17, 2016 Subject:
The film's concept is clear- but it fails utterly
This has plenty of reviews, so I didn't think it needed another one until I realized that no one seems to have noticed that the film is almost completely ineffectual. The filmmakers do not prove their case. What we see are shots of machines, appliances, and various "modern" conveniences interspersed with people who are (mostly) not interacting with each other. There is no trace of a causal link until the very end, when we see people choosing to watch television rather than spending time with each other. For most of the film? We see parking meters. Are parking meters alienating? We see telephones and hear telephone conversations. Surely we are not supposed to believe that telephones- that let us connect with people all over the world, instantly- separate us from each other? Dishwashers- do they make you feel alone in the world? How about cute, clever little cigarette boxes? I would think they would inspire conversation, not the reverse. Cash registers, elevators, and traffic lights are not the reasons that people don't connect with one another. On the contrary, these are all places where people congregate- and, perhaps, exchange lively remarks about each other's driving habits. And bringing roller skates into the argument is low down. Is nothing sacred?
June 23, 2016 Subject:
Controlled by our things
It's the 'Internet of Things' gone wild! 50's style.
February 19, 2016 Subject:
An Incredible Film
An incredible film which is almost dystopian, except that it's sadly quite factual. Interestingly, I would argue that we've actually come back a little from this sort of disconnectedness with humanity - although appliances are far more prevalent in our lives, we are much more connected socially than ever before.
By the way, the song on the radio when the husband is driving to work is "Paddlin' Madeline Home," and it's the version sung by the Whitey Kaufman Orchestra. That doggone song was an earworm off and on for years, and it took me forever to try to track it down as I couldn't understand any of the lyrics!
July 7, 2015 Subject:
Too late now ...
Don't worry about this family. In a few years, the kid will have his own hot rod and get busted for pot at a rock and roll concert. This will traumatize the mom, who will divorce the dad and hitchhike to Sausalito to find herself. The dad's company will lay his cold-fish ass off and he'll have to sell the house and Caddy and move into a sad LA-noir apartment, become a private eye and start drinking heavily.
This film has a short clip of a telephone step office in action along with the old pulse dialer.
February 22, 2013 Subject:
Dark and Darker
This film is intended to be a warning more than anything. New technology was hitting the common man increasingly the decade after World War II. The noises, clicks and whirls tend to drown out the silence and words between us.
I was 10 years old in 1958. My father was an industrial engineer and made good money. We had brand new cars, modern up to date furniture and five kids. My mother wore aprons, but owned her own seamstress design shop. My dad was president of the coin collecting club, very active in the community and my mother as well. She sewed a great deal of our clothes and household decor.
We had a record player, a toaster, a percolator, new washing machine (no dryer yet)...and a radio in the kitchen. We got a television in 1955.
We lived in Ohio.
However, our busy active family DID NOT have the following:
A DISHWASHER!! (though middle-class...they truly weren't affordable yet)
A radio-car phone (are you kidding? Only my uncle the Superintendent of the Cincinnati Water Works had that) I never saw one outside of his and the police.
Did not have two clocks on the bedroom bureau. (my mother was so vigilant and busy....not necessary)
No electric razor.
Most men preferred the old way. I saw dozens of them growing up.
NO TV DINNERS!! I'm not sure where this concept came from....it certainly runs its course as an icon of that time period.
I lived in 5 states by the time I was 16 and I cannot remember a single one in all our homes, or my friends. I had wealthy friends in some cities....very wealthy. TV dinners just weren't the norm. Though it's in this film....even then it was touted as "the thing" to do in modernity I believe.
We had Jiffy Pop and Velveeta. We did consider these products luxurious modern convenience foods.
With five children (and many families had 3 or more back then) it was not practically affordable for a family to buy TV dinners.
We ate home-cooked meat and potatoes meals. Even homemade dessert (though my mother was definitely not a saint...).
We did however have an ice-cream man....he was older, safe and friendly. We went out to get the ice cream without adult supervision.
It was okay back then.
June 18, 2011 Subject:
I was expecting a bigger finish like the husband comes home and the wife has left him or better yet everyone gets fried in a nuclear holocaust. This film is trying to portray the disconnected mechanized lives that this family is living. I was surprised that the doctor didn't prescribe tranquilizers for the wife's symptoms. Sales of Miltown and Equanil skyrocketed in the 50's. There were some really cool shots of machinery and some great historical shots of 1950's LA.
June 17, 2011 Subject:
Depends on the Individual...
I'm not buying what the film is selling. My relatives, (I was born in 1958), laughed, danced, kissed, made love, played poker, pitched horseshoes, pinched asses, told jokes, got drunk, danced, sketched, discussed, read books and a million other things...in such surroundings, with modern conveniences, with stressful jobs, and houses to keep clean. They lived full, vibrant, happy lives in simular settings. The problem lies with the individuals in charge of their lives, not modernity.
June 17, 2011 Subject:
So who - or what - do you love?
A superb treatment of "the modern life" in pre-transisterized L.A. The limits of human interaction for the father are a push of the button, nod of the head, mass media, or via telephone. The mother only speaks directly to her child one time - telling him it's time for bed. The son doesn't speak at all, and far prefers the company of his green glowing friend to any other, even other children. (Granted it could have been well over 100 degrees on a hot LA summer day, so playing is uncomfortable, and merely sitting still eating ice cream is the only relief.) No video games or Internet to create even an illusion of interaction.
No human touches another throughout the film.
Even so, this family is "living the good life". Father drives a new car, the home is furnished in amazing mid-century modern style , and their every convenience is repaired immediately when needed. They're even a "two alarm family"! Food is plentiful and affordable, yet the choices made - or not made - indicate a definite lack of nutritional knowledge or availability.
Interestingly, the mother is told by the doctor that "there is no organic cause" for her "not feeling well". I would hazard a LACK of organics in her life is a major cause. The son is the only one in this film to see daylight, and that only long enough to get an ice cream. He then goes back to the tv. No fresh or colored food is seen. The only animal is one cat frightened by father's car horn. The only time spent "in nature" is when father gets his evening paper off the well manicured and automatically sprinklered lawn. It's not that mother isn't feeling well, but rather that she is having no feelings at all. A simple application of mother's little helper after her next doctor's appointment should fix her right up...
What the son is learning about relationships and family dynamics is appalling, but probably moot as he will most likely die in Viet Nam.
The parents are of the age to have been infants in the latter part of the Depression, and children during the War. Coming out of the Lost Generation, and through the terrors of war may certainly have colored their personalities with unnamed fears of loss and poverty, and instilled the "virtues" of stoic suffering and hard work.
Only one time does the mother even appear to do housework, when she rinses the dishes and puts them in the automatic washer. Yet the house is pristine, organized, and on a certain schedule.
This film is full of wonderful small clips of automated machinery, relays, pulleys, buttons all "working the world" around our hapless players. Very fascinating and fun to see.
Has the change from solid state to digital machinery allowed us to have a better life?
Would this family love each other if they didn't have all these machines? It appears their problems run much deeper than time saving tools! So tell your computer and Xbox that you love them. Then get up and hug your SO!
June 25, 2006 Subject:
Everyone has free will, but with a little fear or compliance, and a bit of repetition we can be conditioned into about any routine, any frame of thought, any belief system, and any destructive social habits.
It would seem that up to this point, a human's will or free will and self awareness always falls secondary to man's will to by hypnotised!
January 30, 2006 Subject:
"Life is just a series of sensations, some to be desired, others to be avoided."
Many of the archived films on this site from this era are very obvious and direct in the message and filmmaking style. "Have I Told You" is quite unique for this era in its effective use of creative camera angles, rich irony, and silence.
Despite all of the modern conveniences, communication technology, transportation, and entertainment, the family is so dysfunctional that no device can help them or make them happier. They are surrounded with the best of their times (which makes for fascinating historical reference or video sampling), which gives them more opportunity than ever to interact with each other. Yet, they CHOOSE not to. Instead, each of them absorbs themself in some petty device, technology or entertainment -- the husband with his cigarette holder, the boy in the TV, and wife in all of her time-saving kitchen appliances.
The greatest irony of the film comes at the end, as the wife is watching TV, interspersed with shots of the husband eating his TV dinner. The couple on TV talk about how much they love each other, enjoy talking to each other, and how they feel safe together... while the husband and wife in the film coldly walk past each other. They have everything of their time, yet fall short of its idea.
January 12, 2006 Subject:
Life is Nothing but a Series of Sensations . . .
A bleak film about how the mechanized quality of everyday life diminishes human interactions. We follow a lonely family through their day, where dad, mom and son interact with clocks, cars, telephones, coffeepots, radio and television instead of each other. Have all these objects made their life so dismal, or do they simply amplify a sense of estrangement that was already there? The wifeÃÂs life seems the most desolate; sheÃÂs home alone all day with a dead-eyed son who does nothing but watch TV. SheÃÂs got health problems and takes a long drag on her cigarette as she talks to her doctor. The husband seems to have the best of it, at least he gets out of the house all day. But when he comes home, thereÃÂs nothing but a TV dinner for him; his wife is obviously too depressed to cook. Refreshingly for the fifties, the film doesnÃÂt blame the wife for the familyÃÂs predicament. SheÃÂs a victim of modern life like everybody else. And who knows? Maybe at one point, she got up and made her husbandÃÂs breakfast before he went to work and slaved over home-cooked meals. But with an unappreciative husband and son, she eventually gave up.
November 28, 2005 Subject:
Automation can alienate
This film warns that modern technology can isolate peeople. It goes to negative extremes. This film was made in 1958. We have advanced even more now, but plenty of people are still communicating. It's how you deal with things.
August 22, 2005 Subject:
Early Zombie Flick?
The folks are zombified! It is not that technology gets in the way of them communicating with one another, they simply choose not to. There were plenty of opportunities for interpersonal communication, but they seem to be in so much of a daze that they can't take advantage of them. If they were really this far gone, they would not be able to function.
This is a very grim look at technology and automation. Too much so. Its like the mom had a lobotomy!
I do like the final shot, however. **Possible Spoiler** The father's lighter does not work and he has to take out an old fashioned match to get his cigarette lit.
Very depressing and unrealistic.
April 10, 2004 Subject:
A swell film about a not so swell existance.
Odd, strangely depressing, weird.
I like this thing, whatever it is...
September 22, 2003 Subject:
Cold, heartless and fascnating.
A very odd and troubling film, which, on the surface seems to tell about how wonderful automation is in 1958 America. But, as time goes on, what it REALLY is about is how automation seems to have detached everyone from everyone else. Very little is said to one other directly. Whenever someone DOES say something to each other it's either a) through technology or b) not responded to at all. The Husband, Wife, and Child in the film never seem to converse to each other (except when the Mother tells the kid to go to bed, the kid doesnt answer, he just goes off).
Has technology led us to be robots in our normal social lives? Even at the end of the film, when the husband gets a cigarette from a gawdy cigarette carousel, he's not impressed with it at all, it's just there to give him a smoke.
It's a very peculiar subject, which is well documented in this film. This is a MUST SEE on this site, but be warned, it's not upbeat.
September 11, 2003 Subject:
Technology in modern life - the b/w version
Had Jacques Tati made American industrial film noir, it would look like this.